(Week 2 - Thursday Aug. 7)
As early as 1652, the Colony of Massachusetts had experienced a chronic shortage of circulating medium (i.e. lack of an adequate money supply), and so tried to remedy this situation by opening a mint to strike its own coins. This provided only very temporary relief, as the new coins soon found their way back to London in exchange for manufactured goods. The Colony remained poor and in debt to England, and its early commerce and development were severely stunted.
Then in February 1690, they got the idea for a "radical" solution to this problem. The Colony began to print its own money, called "bills of credit." By July 1692 these notes were declared "legal tender" (i.e. good for paying all debts), and began to circulate freely. These bills became the first government-issued paper money in the history of the Western world. What is more, they were not "backed" by gold, silver, commodities, land banks, mortgage contracts, or other schemes which mainly facilitate control of the system by an elite portion of the population. Rather they were issued publicly, in proportion to the practical need for a money supply, out the natural right of a society to issue its own money, and backed only by the free economic activity of the people of the Colony as a whole.
Massachusetts prospered with its newly printed "scrip" (paper money), and the other colonies soon copied its example. The Crown set itself in continuous opposition to these unapproved issues, and Parliament passed laws in an attempt to curb them. This set up conditions whereby there arose an open and widespread violation of the law, even by merchants and statesmen. Bonds of nationhood began to form, even as the colonist's unapproved currency facilitated its physical development. This, in turn, created an effective training ground for resisting subjugation which eventually found expression in Revolution. According to monetary historian
Steve Zarlenga:
"The skirmishes at Lexington and Concord are considered the start of the Revolt, but the point of no return was probably May 10, 1775 when the Continental Congress assumed the power of sovereignty by issuing its own money."
Ben Franklin served in France as America's first ambassador. When asked about how he could explain the prosperous condition of the Colonies, he replied:
"That is simple. It is only because in the Colonies we issue our own money. It is called colonial scrip, and we issue it in proper proportion to the demand of trade and industry."
We as a society have been subjected to much myth-making regarding the American Revolution. Selected parts have been endlessly quoted and manipulated to promote partial agendas. I would assert that, without sufficient understanding of the central importance of the struggle over who had the right to create, issue and control the colonies' money supply (the public through its elected representatives – vs.- the monarchy through the Bank of England), we cannot comprehend fully the meaning of the Revolution. We need to understand what Franklin meant when he said:
"The Colonies would gladly have borne the little tax on tea and other matters had it not been that England took away from the Colonies (the right to issue) their money, which created unemployment and dissatisfaction."
This leads us back to the inspiration behind the Concord Resolution, which I will take up in tomorrow's column.
Richard Kotlarz
http://us.mc366.mail.yahoo.com/mc/compose?to=richkotlarz@gmail.com
The complete set of columns from this series is posted at the following websites:
http://economictree.blogspot.com/
http://www.concordresolution.org/column.htm
Thursday, August 7, 2008
Wednesday, August 6, 2008
Column #9 The Concord Resolution
(Week 2 - Wednesday Aug. 6)
In the last two columns I have put forth the idea that public money issued out of the U.S. Treasury is the economic, legal and moral way to finance essential public works. This is a concept that is not new to the history of our nation, but it has been forgotten in our time by all but a very rare few.
But now, a vanguard of brave souls in and around the town of Concord, Massachusetts has revived the idea, and is seeking to put it back on the national agenda in the form of an initiative dubbed "The Concord Resolution." This is a grassroots educational and political effort aimed at formulating and bringing to the Concord town meeting a Warrant Article ("resolution" in more common language) to petition the town's Congressional representatives to introduce a bill which would set up a procedure whereby counties and municipalities across the nation could, in an orderly way, apply for interest-free loans issued directly out of the U.S. Treasury to pay for essential public works. This is in lieu of their feeling obliged to sell bonds on the private bond market to raise needed funds.
The problem with the bond method is that it typically causes the financial cost of the project to double or triple due to "interest" payments made to bond dealers and speculators. What the Concord Resolution proposes is the complete elimination of these "interest" fees through the issuance of public money for public works.
The town of Concord is a relatively wealthy community that in an immediate sense stands certainly in lesser need of the money-saving virtues of this proposed measure than others across the nation. Why, then, has the initiative arisen from this particular locale? The good citizens of Concord deserve some recognition for that. They are sensible people who, naturally, do not wish to pay any more money than is right and necessary for their schools, roads, bridges, parks and utilities.
Beyond that, there is a growing realization that this in not only good for building public works and saving taxes in their town, but is indeed necessary to redeeming the crumbling physical infrastructure of the nation as a whole.
Taking the idea a step further, this may be a first practical step to, not only save the cost of the "interest" charges on public works across the nation, but, more fundamentally, to redeem the American monetary system itself. What is more, the fact that this resolution arises from the soil of Massachusetts has profound historical significance. These are bold statements, I know. They will be the topic of tomorrow's discourse.
Richard Kotlarz
richkotlarz@gmail.com
Postscript: For more information on the Concord Resolution go to http://www.concordresolution.org/
In the last two columns I have put forth the idea that public money issued out of the U.S. Treasury is the economic, legal and moral way to finance essential public works. This is a concept that is not new to the history of our nation, but it has been forgotten in our time by all but a very rare few.
But now, a vanguard of brave souls in and around the town of Concord, Massachusetts has revived the idea, and is seeking to put it back on the national agenda in the form of an initiative dubbed "The Concord Resolution." This is a grassroots educational and political effort aimed at formulating and bringing to the Concord town meeting a Warrant Article ("resolution" in more common language) to petition the town's Congressional representatives to introduce a bill which would set up a procedure whereby counties and municipalities across the nation could, in an orderly way, apply for interest-free loans issued directly out of the U.S. Treasury to pay for essential public works. This is in lieu of their feeling obliged to sell bonds on the private bond market to raise needed funds.
The problem with the bond method is that it typically causes the financial cost of the project to double or triple due to "interest" payments made to bond dealers and speculators. What the Concord Resolution proposes is the complete elimination of these "interest" fees through the issuance of public money for public works.
The town of Concord is a relatively wealthy community that in an immediate sense stands certainly in lesser need of the money-saving virtues of this proposed measure than others across the nation. Why, then, has the initiative arisen from this particular locale? The good citizens of Concord deserve some recognition for that. They are sensible people who, naturally, do not wish to pay any more money than is right and necessary for their schools, roads, bridges, parks and utilities.
Beyond that, there is a growing realization that this in not only good for building public works and saving taxes in their town, but is indeed necessary to redeeming the crumbling physical infrastructure of the nation as a whole.
Taking the idea a step further, this may be a first practical step to, not only save the cost of the "interest" charges on public works across the nation, but, more fundamentally, to redeem the American monetary system itself. What is more, the fact that this resolution arises from the soil of Massachusetts has profound historical significance. These are bold statements, I know. They will be the topic of tomorrow's discourse.
Richard Kotlarz
richkotlarz@gmail.com
Postscript: For more information on the Concord Resolution go to http://www.concordresolution.org/
Tuesday, August 5, 2008
Column #8 Ford & Edison on Financing of Public Works
(Week 2 - Tuesday Aug. 5)
Yesterday I put forth the idea that the natural way to finance essential public works is to create and issue the necessary funds directly out of the U.S. Treasury. This would limit the cost of the project to payment for actual work done, and avoid multiplying the "cost" by, typically, a factor of two or three due to "interest" charges attached to the money. I have often been met with looks of incredulity when I have proposed such a thing. If this is such an obvious method, some say, why is it not talked about all the time in the debates about how to finance public works?
This is a fair question, but it is not possible to do it justice within the limitations of this short missive. I suggest that a fuller answer will unfold over the course of this dialogue. For now suffice it to say that such matters have indeed been debated as part of the great economic heritage of this nation, but we have as a people have virtually forgotten our heritage. It would be easy to invoke a veritable chorus of voices from our past to buttress this argument, but for now the subject is public financing of public works, so permit me to offer the following as a case in point.
During the 1920's Henry Ford and Thomas Edison teamed up in an article in the December 6, 1921 edition of the New York Times to express their views on the monetary system, and to propose that the Federal government issue currency, rather than bonds, to finance the huge Muscle Shoals nitrate plant in the Tennessee River Valley.
Ford asserted:
"The function of money is not to make money but to move goods."
"The youth who can solve the money question will do more for the world than all the professional soldiers of history."
"It is well that the people of the Nation do not understand our banking and monetary system, for if they did, I believe there would be a revolution before tomorrow morning."
Thomas Edison added:
"If our nation can issue dollar bond, it can issue a dollar bill. The element that makes the bond good makes the bill good, also. The difference between the bond and the bill is that the bond lets the money broker collect . . . whereas the currency pays nobody but those who contribute . . . in some useful way."
"If the Government issues a bond, it simply induces the money brokers to draw $30,000,000 out of the other channels of trade . . . if the Government issues currency, it provides itself with enough money to increase the national wealth . . . without disturbing the business of the rest of the country. And in doing this it increases its income without adding a penny to its debt."
". . . it is the people who constitute the basis of government credit. Why then cannot the people have the benefit of their own guilt-edged credit by receiving non-interest-bearing currency . . . instead of bankers receiving the benefit of the people's credit in interest-bearing bonds?"
"If the United States Government will adopt this policy of increasing its national wealth without contributing to the interest collector – for the whole national debt is made up of interest charges – then you will see an era of progress and prosperity in this country such as would never have come otherwise."
"And it is the control of money that constitutes the money question. It is the control of money that is the root of all evil."
"There is a complete set of misleading slogans kept on hand for just such outbreaks of common sense among the people. The people are so ignorant of what they think are the intricacies of the money system that they are easily impressed by big words. There would be new shrieks of 'fiat money,' and 'paper money,' and 'greenbackism,' and all the rest of it – the same old cries with which the people have been shouted down from the beginning."
"Ford's idea is flawless. They won't like it. They will fight it, but the people of this country ought to take it up and think about it. I believe it points to many reforms and achievements which cannot come under the old system."
In fact, there is a group of citizens who have taken up the idea and are trying to create an initiative to make public financing of public works a reality. I will pick up on that thread in tomorrow's column.
Richard Kotlarz
richkotlarz@gmail.com
The complete set of columns from this series is posted at the following websites.
http://economictree.blogspot.com/
http://www.concordresolution.org/welcome.htm
Yesterday I put forth the idea that the natural way to finance essential public works is to create and issue the necessary funds directly out of the U.S. Treasury. This would limit the cost of the project to payment for actual work done, and avoid multiplying the "cost" by, typically, a factor of two or three due to "interest" charges attached to the money. I have often been met with looks of incredulity when I have proposed such a thing. If this is such an obvious method, some say, why is it not talked about all the time in the debates about how to finance public works?
This is a fair question, but it is not possible to do it justice within the limitations of this short missive. I suggest that a fuller answer will unfold over the course of this dialogue. For now suffice it to say that such matters have indeed been debated as part of the great economic heritage of this nation, but we have as a people have virtually forgotten our heritage. It would be easy to invoke a veritable chorus of voices from our past to buttress this argument, but for now the subject is public financing of public works, so permit me to offer the following as a case in point.
During the 1920's Henry Ford and Thomas Edison teamed up in an article in the December 6, 1921 edition of the New York Times to express their views on the monetary system, and to propose that the Federal government issue currency, rather than bonds, to finance the huge Muscle Shoals nitrate plant in the Tennessee River Valley.
Ford asserted:
"The function of money is not to make money but to move goods."
"The youth who can solve the money question will do more for the world than all the professional soldiers of history."
"It is well that the people of the Nation do not understand our banking and monetary system, for if they did, I believe there would be a revolution before tomorrow morning."
Thomas Edison added:
"If our nation can issue dollar bond, it can issue a dollar bill. The element that makes the bond good makes the bill good, also. The difference between the bond and the bill is that the bond lets the money broker collect . . . whereas the currency pays nobody but those who contribute . . . in some useful way."
"If the Government issues a bond, it simply induces the money brokers to draw $30,000,000 out of the other channels of trade . . . if the Government issues currency, it provides itself with enough money to increase the national wealth . . . without disturbing the business of the rest of the country. And in doing this it increases its income without adding a penny to its debt."
". . . it is the people who constitute the basis of government credit. Why then cannot the people have the benefit of their own guilt-edged credit by receiving non-interest-bearing currency . . . instead of bankers receiving the benefit of the people's credit in interest-bearing bonds?"
"If the United States Government will adopt this policy of increasing its national wealth without contributing to the interest collector – for the whole national debt is made up of interest charges – then you will see an era of progress and prosperity in this country such as would never have come otherwise."
"And it is the control of money that constitutes the money question. It is the control of money that is the root of all evil."
"There is a complete set of misleading slogans kept on hand for just such outbreaks of common sense among the people. The people are so ignorant of what they think are the intricacies of the money system that they are easily impressed by big words. There would be new shrieks of 'fiat money,' and 'paper money,' and 'greenbackism,' and all the rest of it – the same old cries with which the people have been shouted down from the beginning."
"Ford's idea is flawless. They won't like it. They will fight it, but the people of this country ought to take it up and think about it. I believe it points to many reforms and achievements which cannot come under the old system."
In fact, there is a group of citizens who have taken up the idea and are trying to create an initiative to make public financing of public works a reality. I will pick up on that thread in tomorrow's column.
Richard Kotlarz
richkotlarz@gmail.com
The complete set of columns from this series is posted at the following websites.
http://economictree.blogspot.com/
http://www.concordresolution.org/welcome.htm
Sunday, August 3, 2008
Column #7 Anniversary of a Bridge Collapse
(Week 2 - Monday Aug. 4)
I am writing this column little more than a mile away from where the Interstate 35W bridge over the Mississippi River in Minneapolis collapsed on August 1 of last year. This tragedy that took the lives of 13 people was marked over the weekend in somber memorial events. These were accompanied by lamentations throughout the media that the nation has taken few steps since this "wake-up call" to rejuvenate its crumbling infrastructure. The determination on the part of the body public to rectify this deplorable situation is, it seems, still there, but where is the money? I would assert that it is readily available. We just aren't seeing it.
The I35W bridge is part of what might be termed the "commons"; i.e. the property that is held in common by all the people for the benefit of the common good. The "commons," of course, includes almost all bridges, roads, schools, emergency services, parks, provisions for the common defense, and other public assets that are indispensable to the full pursuit of life, liberty and happiness in a healthy society. There is, however, one element of the commons that is perhaps the most essential, and yet I have never specifically heard it recognized as such. It is our "money." It is the one element of the public domain that we all hold most in common.
Think about it. Anyone in the nation was free (while it was standing) to pass over the I35W bridge in Minneapolis, but in reality only a very small portion of the population of the nation ever would. What is more, after the bridge went down, ways of circumventing it locally were quickly identified, and the life of the city went on essentially normally. The bridge served the nation, but only a small portion directly.
Now think about a dollar in your pocket. It looks exactly like the dollar in anyone else's pocket. Do you not let it rest there complacent in the assurance that it can be brought out when needed to pay for anything a dollar will buy? This could be for a cup of coffee (assuming one can find one that cheaply these days) in New York, California, Florida, Alaska or Minnesota. Is this not an assurance that we all hold blithely from corner to corner of the nation, even to the point of hardly actually thinking about it? Is not our money in fact the most commonly held and used element of the public domain?
The founders of our country knew how essential public ownership of public money was. That is why, for example, the Colonies before the Revolution insisted on the right to issue their own currency ("bills of credit"), instead of having to borrow their money supply from a private bank (Bank of England) at "interest." It is why they financed the establishment of the nation with the publicly issued "Continental Currency." It is also why, when the nation was again locked in a struggle for its very existence, Abraham Lincoln issued $450 million dollars worth of publicly issued bills, popularly known as the "Greenbacks" (after, of course, coming under intense pressure to borrow the money from banks).
This first anniversary of the Minneapolis bridge collapse is a reminder that the nation is again under threat, in part from the crumbling of its very physical base, and as before, money borrowed at "interest" from banks is not going to save it. In fact, I would argue, the reliance on debt-based private money is how we got into this predicament. It has for some generations been the norm that when any community, be it local or the nation as a whole, saw the need to make investments in the common infrastructure, it was faced with the (assumed) necessity of paying for the project two or three times over due to the compounding "interest" charge attached to money needed to implement the project. This means that over the years a vast amount if infrastructure construction and revitalization did not get funded. Part of the cost of that backlog manifested in Minneapolis, and it proved to be high. In New Orleans it was incalculable. What will be the physical and human costs in the future?
We as a nation have forgotten that money too (perhaps money above all) is a fundamental element of the commons. Why, then, cannot public money be issued out of the Constitutional authority of the Congress "To coin Money, regulate the Value thereof . . ." to provide for the common good (a critical bridge or levee when needed)? The answer, I believe, is that it can be done, and is indeed the economic, legal and moral way to finance essential public works.
Richard Kotlarz
richkotlarz@gmail.com
I am writing this column little more than a mile away from where the Interstate 35W bridge over the Mississippi River in Minneapolis collapsed on August 1 of last year. This tragedy that took the lives of 13 people was marked over the weekend in somber memorial events. These were accompanied by lamentations throughout the media that the nation has taken few steps since this "wake-up call" to rejuvenate its crumbling infrastructure. The determination on the part of the body public to rectify this deplorable situation is, it seems, still there, but where is the money? I would assert that it is readily available. We just aren't seeing it.
The I35W bridge is part of what might be termed the "commons"; i.e. the property that is held in common by all the people for the benefit of the common good. The "commons," of course, includes almost all bridges, roads, schools, emergency services, parks, provisions for the common defense, and other public assets that are indispensable to the full pursuit of life, liberty and happiness in a healthy society. There is, however, one element of the commons that is perhaps the most essential, and yet I have never specifically heard it recognized as such. It is our "money." It is the one element of the public domain that we all hold most in common.
Think about it. Anyone in the nation was free (while it was standing) to pass over the I35W bridge in Minneapolis, but in reality only a very small portion of the population of the nation ever would. What is more, after the bridge went down, ways of circumventing it locally were quickly identified, and the life of the city went on essentially normally. The bridge served the nation, but only a small portion directly.
Now think about a dollar in your pocket. It looks exactly like the dollar in anyone else's pocket. Do you not let it rest there complacent in the assurance that it can be brought out when needed to pay for anything a dollar will buy? This could be for a cup of coffee (assuming one can find one that cheaply these days) in New York, California, Florida, Alaska or Minnesota. Is this not an assurance that we all hold blithely from corner to corner of the nation, even to the point of hardly actually thinking about it? Is not our money in fact the most commonly held and used element of the public domain?
The founders of our country knew how essential public ownership of public money was. That is why, for example, the Colonies before the Revolution insisted on the right to issue their own currency ("bills of credit"), instead of having to borrow their money supply from a private bank (Bank of England) at "interest." It is why they financed the establishment of the nation with the publicly issued "Continental Currency." It is also why, when the nation was again locked in a struggle for its very existence, Abraham Lincoln issued $450 million dollars worth of publicly issued bills, popularly known as the "Greenbacks" (after, of course, coming under intense pressure to borrow the money from banks).
This first anniversary of the Minneapolis bridge collapse is a reminder that the nation is again under threat, in part from the crumbling of its very physical base, and as before, money borrowed at "interest" from banks is not going to save it. In fact, I would argue, the reliance on debt-based private money is how we got into this predicament. It has for some generations been the norm that when any community, be it local or the nation as a whole, saw the need to make investments in the common infrastructure, it was faced with the (assumed) necessity of paying for the project two or three times over due to the compounding "interest" charge attached to money needed to implement the project. This means that over the years a vast amount if infrastructure construction and revitalization did not get funded. Part of the cost of that backlog manifested in Minneapolis, and it proved to be high. In New Orleans it was incalculable. What will be the physical and human costs in the future?
We as a nation have forgotten that money too (perhaps money above all) is a fundamental element of the commons. Why, then, cannot public money be issued out of the Constitutional authority of the Congress "To coin Money, regulate the Value thereof . . ." to provide for the common good (a critical bridge or levee when needed)? The answer, I believe, is that it can be done, and is indeed the economic, legal and moral way to finance essential public works.
Richard Kotlarz
richkotlarz@gmail.com
Column #6 Recap of Private Bank Loan Transaction
(Week 1 -Saturday Aug. 2)
In Col. 3 I posed the query, "Where does our money come from?", and then suggested that for greater specificity the question could be broken down into three parts. These can now be answered concisely:
(1) What is the procedure by which dollars are created? – Dollars are created in the moment a banker "writes the check" to, or credits the account of, a person who is in the process of borrowing money from a private bank. The principal sum of the "loan" is newly-created money.
(2) How do they enter into circulation? – These newly-created dollars enter into circulation when the person who takes out the loan spends the money for whatever purpose the loan was taken out for.
(3) Who controls the process? – The money creation process is controlled by a private banking system.
In Col. 4, "The Problem of Interest," I made what to many must seem to be, at least a bold, perhaps an outlandish assertion that the attachment of a compounding "interest" fee to the basic private bank loan transaction by which our money is created and enters into circulation constitutes "the very engine of the economic trauma we are facing at the present time." This point can also be described in three parts:
(1) Within the present system, there is attached to the issuance of money a compounding "interest" charge. By the terms of the basic bank loan transaction, the money to repay the principal sum of the loan was created and issued, but the money to pay the "interest" was not.
(2) This leads to a situation whereby the money to make the "interest" payments can only come from (be taken out of) the outstanding principal balance of other people's loans still in circulation.
(3) This creates the effective necessity for people in the economy as a whole to go deeper into "debt" (i.e. borrow and spend more money into circulation) on a continuous basis in order to make the principal payments on old "debt," keep up with the demand for ever-compounding "interest" payments, plus maintain enough money in circulation to have an adequate money supply.
Finally, in Col.5, I offered an answer to the question, "Where Does Our Money Go?" when we make a payment on a loan we took out from a private bank. I said that the bank divides the payments received into two parts. Again, this process can be summed up in three points:
(1) One part of the payment is applied to retiring the principal sum of the money borrowed. This money is extinguished, and no longer exists.
(2) The other part, the payment on the "interest", is not extinguished, but passes into the account of a speculator who has purchased the contract by which the loan was secured (the contract signed by the borrower).
(3) The speculator who buys the contract, typically, is not interested in returning the money to circulation within the public money supply, which he could do by simply spending his profit from holding the loan contract. Rather, he elects to "re-invest" the money. That is to say, he holds it out of circulation until he finds someone who is willing to borrow his money at still more interest. The new borrower, then, will spend it back into the monetary stream.
This "re-investment" can take on many guises (which we will talk about as these columns unfold). In any case, the net effect is to cause the "debt" burden against the money supply to grow, without increasing the size of the money supply. As these "interest"-payment dollars are loaned back into circulation there are no new dollars created and spent into the money supply, but these "interest"-payment dollars have thereby been transformed into new "debt". The resulting shortfall in the money supply in relation to the "debt-load" it is obliged to support eventually forces someone to go to a bank to borrow-&-spend more money into circulation, which, in turn, initiates a whole new round of the private-bank-loan, debt-money-creation process.
While for simplicity I am describing this cycle in terms of an isolated case, it is a process that happens millions of times daily, and is causing the nation's, and now the world's, economy to sink ever further under a crushing "debt" burden. I have never found this described in any explicit way in the media. In fact, I have found it very difficult to find an explicit description of what is happening in academic offerings, yet the way money is created at present is the very engine that is driving our economic distress. I would suggest that we will never see what lies behind the headlines unless we understand the nature of the money-creation-by-private-bank-loan transaction.
If I seem to belabor this point, I ask the reader's patience. I feel that the relatively small amount of time spent in coming to an understanding of how our money is created and controlled will pay great dividends in arriving at an understanding of what we are seeing in the news. I thank you for your considerate patience.
Beginning Monday, I will return more explicitly to the financial stories appearing in the media, but this time with the basis for a new way to talk about them. Hopefully, a deeper truth about what they are saying about our economic lives will be revealed. Whether or not this proves to be so is, ultimately, up to the reader. I welcome any questions, thoughts and commentary.
My sincere thanks for your thoughtful consideration,
Richard Kotlarz
richkotlarz@gmail.com
In Col. 3 I posed the query, "Where does our money come from?", and then suggested that for greater specificity the question could be broken down into three parts. These can now be answered concisely:
(1) What is the procedure by which dollars are created? – Dollars are created in the moment a banker "writes the check" to, or credits the account of, a person who is in the process of borrowing money from a private bank. The principal sum of the "loan" is newly-created money.
(2) How do they enter into circulation? – These newly-created dollars enter into circulation when the person who takes out the loan spends the money for whatever purpose the loan was taken out for.
(3) Who controls the process? – The money creation process is controlled by a private banking system.
In Col. 4, "The Problem of Interest," I made what to many must seem to be, at least a bold, perhaps an outlandish assertion that the attachment of a compounding "interest" fee to the basic private bank loan transaction by which our money is created and enters into circulation constitutes "the very engine of the economic trauma we are facing at the present time." This point can also be described in three parts:
(1) Within the present system, there is attached to the issuance of money a compounding "interest" charge. By the terms of the basic bank loan transaction, the money to repay the principal sum of the loan was created and issued, but the money to pay the "interest" was not.
(2) This leads to a situation whereby the money to make the "interest" payments can only come from (be taken out of) the outstanding principal balance of other people's loans still in circulation.
(3) This creates the effective necessity for people in the economy as a whole to go deeper into "debt" (i.e. borrow and spend more money into circulation) on a continuous basis in order to make the principal payments on old "debt," keep up with the demand for ever-compounding "interest" payments, plus maintain enough money in circulation to have an adequate money supply.
Finally, in Col.5, I offered an answer to the question, "Where Does Our Money Go?" when we make a payment on a loan we took out from a private bank. I said that the bank divides the payments received into two parts. Again, this process can be summed up in three points:
(1) One part of the payment is applied to retiring the principal sum of the money borrowed. This money is extinguished, and no longer exists.
(2) The other part, the payment on the "interest", is not extinguished, but passes into the account of a speculator who has purchased the contract by which the loan was secured (the contract signed by the borrower).
(3) The speculator who buys the contract, typically, is not interested in returning the money to circulation within the public money supply, which he could do by simply spending his profit from holding the loan contract. Rather, he elects to "re-invest" the money. That is to say, he holds it out of circulation until he finds someone who is willing to borrow his money at still more interest. The new borrower, then, will spend it back into the monetary stream.
This "re-investment" can take on many guises (which we will talk about as these columns unfold). In any case, the net effect is to cause the "debt" burden against the money supply to grow, without increasing the size of the money supply. As these "interest"-payment dollars are loaned back into circulation there are no new dollars created and spent into the money supply, but these "interest"-payment dollars have thereby been transformed into new "debt". The resulting shortfall in the money supply in relation to the "debt-load" it is obliged to support eventually forces someone to go to a bank to borrow-&-spend more money into circulation, which, in turn, initiates a whole new round of the private-bank-loan, debt-money-creation process.
While for simplicity I am describing this cycle in terms of an isolated case, it is a process that happens millions of times daily, and is causing the nation's, and now the world's, economy to sink ever further under a crushing "debt" burden. I have never found this described in any explicit way in the media. In fact, I have found it very difficult to find an explicit description of what is happening in academic offerings, yet the way money is created at present is the very engine that is driving our economic distress. I would suggest that we will never see what lies behind the headlines unless we understand the nature of the money-creation-by-private-bank-loan transaction.
If I seem to belabor this point, I ask the reader's patience. I feel that the relatively small amount of time spent in coming to an understanding of how our money is created and controlled will pay great dividends in arriving at an understanding of what we are seeing in the news. I thank you for your considerate patience.
Beginning Monday, I will return more explicitly to the financial stories appearing in the media, but this time with the basis for a new way to talk about them. Hopefully, a deeper truth about what they are saying about our economic lives will be revealed. Whether or not this proves to be so is, ultimately, up to the reader. I welcome any questions, thoughts and commentary.
My sincere thanks for your thoughtful consideration,
Richard Kotlarz
richkotlarz@gmail.com
Column #5 Where Does Our Money Go?
(Week 1 - Friday Aug. 1)
Two days ago, in Col. 3, we examined the question "Where does our money come from?" I described a the classic bank-loan process whereby the banker actually creates the money "loaned" when he "writes the check" (or credits the borrowers account with new funds), and then the borrower puts the money into circulation when he spends it for whatever purpose he took out the loan to satisfy.
Yesterday, in Col. 4, we examined the "problem of interest." That is, I described how the total outstanding principle balances of all loans from the banking system constitute the money supply with which we conduct our business, and that, in the aggregate, the money to pay back the principal sum of the all these loans is thereby available. I also pointed out that the money needed to make the "interest" payments was never issued, and so can be obtained only by subtracting it from the outstanding principal balances of other people's loans. This creates a situation whereby for people to continue to repay their loans, make their "interest" payments, and keep in circulation an adequate money supply, those participating in the economy must as a whole go continually deeper into "debt." If that fails to happen within the present system, we all face a catastrophic contraction of the money supply.
The subject for today is, "Where does our money go?" Our money circulates between the participants in the economy until we make a payment on our loan from the bank. When received at the bank, this payment is divided into two parts. A certain portion is applied to the principal sum originally borrowed; i.e. it is credited toward the retirement of the debt. The bank created this money "out of thin air," and it is extinguished "back to thin air." It no longer exists.
The part of the payment applied to the interest, however, is not extinguished, but is credited to the account of the "owner" of the "debt." This is to say, it is paid to whoever bought the rights to the "mortgage" (or whatever contract secured the loan). Typically, banks gather up ("bundle") the contracts, and sell them to speculators who have an interest in being the beneficiaries of the "interest" payments. These "interest" payments constitute the "profit" on the speculator's "investment," and they are deposited in speculators accounts.
Technically, this "interest"-payment money has not been withdrawn from circulation, and so cannot strictly be said to have been subtracted from the money supply. Indeed, it could be freely spent (or gifted to someone) by the investor, and in that way reenter the money supply, where it would still be available to pay back the principal balances on outstanding loans.
In practice, though, by far the majority of investors in "debt-paper" or "debt-instruments" (as such mortgages or other debt contracts might be called) are not interested in spending the profits. Their purpose is to turn them into still more money. Typically, they will withhold the money they collect from interest payments out of general circulation, until, that is, someone offers to borrow it from them ("at interest," of course). This can take many forms (direct lending, buying municipal bonds, buying the rights to more loan contracts, etc.), but in any case it means that this money will re-enter circulation with more "debt" attached to it.
Now we have the same money supply, but an additional "debt"-payback obligation has been added to it. Of course, there is not only one borrower's "interest" payment that is being transferred into and re-lent out of the accounts of monetary speculators, but everyone's. Eventually the entire money supply is run through this interest-payment-converted-to-more-debt mill. Those that have money to "invest" in this particular way (not all investment money fits this description) get richer, and the relatively poorer folks who are working for a living and paying their bills continue going deeper into debt. The "interest" charged on bank loans is (under the current system) the main engine of unearned wealth transfer in the society, and the problems unleashed thereby are written in the dire financial headlines of our morning newspapers.
Richard Kotlarz
richkotlarz@gmail.com
Two days ago, in Col. 3, we examined the question "Where does our money come from?" I described a the classic bank-loan process whereby the banker actually creates the money "loaned" when he "writes the check" (or credits the borrowers account with new funds), and then the borrower puts the money into circulation when he spends it for whatever purpose he took out the loan to satisfy.
Yesterday, in Col. 4, we examined the "problem of interest." That is, I described how the total outstanding principle balances of all loans from the banking system constitute the money supply with which we conduct our business, and that, in the aggregate, the money to pay back the principal sum of the all these loans is thereby available. I also pointed out that the money needed to make the "interest" payments was never issued, and so can be obtained only by subtracting it from the outstanding principal balances of other people's loans. This creates a situation whereby for people to continue to repay their loans, make their "interest" payments, and keep in circulation an adequate money supply, those participating in the economy must as a whole go continually deeper into "debt." If that fails to happen within the present system, we all face a catastrophic contraction of the money supply.
The subject for today is, "Where does our money go?" Our money circulates between the participants in the economy until we make a payment on our loan from the bank. When received at the bank, this payment is divided into two parts. A certain portion is applied to the principal sum originally borrowed; i.e. it is credited toward the retirement of the debt. The bank created this money "out of thin air," and it is extinguished "back to thin air." It no longer exists.
The part of the payment applied to the interest, however, is not extinguished, but is credited to the account of the "owner" of the "debt." This is to say, it is paid to whoever bought the rights to the "mortgage" (or whatever contract secured the loan). Typically, banks gather up ("bundle") the contracts, and sell them to speculators who have an interest in being the beneficiaries of the "interest" payments. These "interest" payments constitute the "profit" on the speculator's "investment," and they are deposited in speculators accounts.
Technically, this "interest"-payment money has not been withdrawn from circulation, and so cannot strictly be said to have been subtracted from the money supply. Indeed, it could be freely spent (or gifted to someone) by the investor, and in that way reenter the money supply, where it would still be available to pay back the principal balances on outstanding loans.
In practice, though, by far the majority of investors in "debt-paper" or "debt-instruments" (as such mortgages or other debt contracts might be called) are not interested in spending the profits. Their purpose is to turn them into still more money. Typically, they will withhold the money they collect from interest payments out of general circulation, until, that is, someone offers to borrow it from them ("at interest," of course). This can take many forms (direct lending, buying municipal bonds, buying the rights to more loan contracts, etc.), but in any case it means that this money will re-enter circulation with more "debt" attached to it.
Now we have the same money supply, but an additional "debt"-payback obligation has been added to it. Of course, there is not only one borrower's "interest" payment that is being transferred into and re-lent out of the accounts of monetary speculators, but everyone's. Eventually the entire money supply is run through this interest-payment-converted-to-more-debt mill. Those that have money to "invest" in this particular way (not all investment money fits this description) get richer, and the relatively poorer folks who are working for a living and paying their bills continue going deeper into debt. The "interest" charged on bank loans is (under the current system) the main engine of unearned wealth transfer in the society, and the problems unleashed thereby are written in the dire financial headlines of our morning newspapers.
Richard Kotlarz
richkotlarz@gmail.com
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)